πŸ—ΊοΈ New Customer Email Journey Map AUDIT

Every touchpoint a 0-order or 1-order customer sees across all Klaviyo flows  |  June 17, 2026

πŸ“§
Email Signup / Lead
Welcome Flow
πŸ‘€
Browses Products
Browse Abandon
πŸ›’
Adds to Cart
Cart Abandon
πŸ’³
Starts Checkout
Checkout Abandon
πŸŽ‰
First Purchase
Post-Purchase
πŸ”
Retention
Cross-Sell / Review
πŸ“§

Stage 1: Entry / Lead Capture

Popup signup, OpenSend, Reclaim, or App install

BMO Welcome Flow LIVE

Trigger: Added to List (popup email signup)  β†’  ID: RYma7z
Note: Two parallel paths β€” "Men" branded path (5 emails) + generic "Evergreen" path (4 emails) with a Boolean branch. Also has sitewide sale drafts ready to swap. Email #4 in generic path offers 10% OFF first order.
2,319 orders/mo
0.67% conv rate
346K recipients/mo

OpenSend Welcome Flow LIVE

Trigger: Added to List (OpenSend identified visitors)  β†’  ID: UGr5R8

OpenSend Reconnect LIVE

Trigger: Metric (OpenSend identify event)  β†’  ID: Yb8daJ

App Welcome Push LIVE

Trigger: App install metric  β†’  IDs: UefJ97 + TthNrV
πŸ‘€

Stage 2: Browse / Session Abandonment

Visitor browses site or views product pages, then leaves

Browse Abandonment β€” Evergreen LIVE

Trigger: Viewed Product metric  β†’  ID: Teekca  (main Klaviyo-sourced traffic)
1,288 orders/mo
0.16% conv rate
802K recipients/mo

Browse Abandonment β€” Reclaim LIVE

Trigger: Viewed Product (Reclaim/OpenSend-sourced)  β†’  ID: WVXRFX
Same content as main Browse Abandon, just sourced from Reclaim/OpenSend profiles

Browse Abandonment β€” Triple Whale LIVE

Trigger: Viewed Product (TW-sourced)  β†’  ID: Y5WWtE

Session Abandonment LIVE

Trigger: Active on Site metric (no product view)  β†’  IDs: UnD6td + WGsJua + SACVi8
πŸ›’

Stage 3: Cart Abandonment

Visitor adds products to cart but doesn't start checkout

Abandoned Cart β€” Shopify Trigger LIVE

Trigger: Added to Cart (Shopify)  β†’  ID: UndFpt
668 orders/mo
0.68% conv rate
98K recipients/mo

Abandoned Cart β€” Reclaim LIVE

Trigger: Added to Cart (Reclaim/OpenSend)  β†’  ID: UCzs7s

Abandoned Cart β€” Triple Whale LIVE

Trigger: Added to Cart (TW)  β†’  ID: RUJJPM

Cart Abandon Push Notifications LIVE

Trigger: Added to Cart  β†’  IDs: Tr55Gb + X9nK3h
πŸ’³

Stage 4: Checkout Abandonment

Visitor starts checkout but doesn't complete β€” this is Hov's screenshot

πŸ” Hov's Screenshot: "Don't Wait Too Long β€” Your 10% off won't last forever"

This is the Cart Abandon Email #3 ("Time is Ticking on Your 10% Off") or similar urgency email from the Cart/Checkout flow. The CTA goes to PDP instead of cart reconstruction. This is a UX issue β€” abandoned cart/checkout emails should deep-link to the cart or checkout with items pre-loaded, not generic PDP.

Abandoned Checkout β€” Evergreen LIVE

Trigger: Started Checkout  β†’  ID: WNRm6D  |  40 actions, 2 branches (A/B test)
Branch A (Legacy β€” ~57% traffic)
Branch B ([ED] Prospect/Customer split β€” ~43% traffic) βœ… WINNER
Prospects (0 orders):
Customers (1+ orders):
Branch B wins: +14% RPR, +12% $/recipient. But Email #2 underperforms (βˆ’18% RPR vs A). Branch split is ~57/43 not 50/50. Prospect unsub rate is 4Γ— higher than Customers (1.43% vs 0.35%).
1,395 orders/mo
1.43% conv rate
97K recipients/mo

Checkout Abandon β€” Reclaim LIVE

Trigger: Started Checkout (Reclaim)  β†’  ID: YevX3A

Checkout Abandon β€” Triple Whale LIVE

Trigger: Started Checkout (TW)  β†’  ID: UH6Whi

Checkout Abandon Push LIVE

Trigger: Started Checkout  β†’  IDs: SGaVcW + SM8swJ
πŸŽ‰

Stage 5: Post-Purchase (1st Order)

Customer places first order β€” what they see next

Post-Purchase Master β€” 1x Path LIVE

Trigger: Placed Order  β†’  ID: UiT79N  |  Branches by purchase count: 1x / 2x / 3x+
388 orders/mo (all paths)
0.09% conv rate
443K recipients/mo

Post-Purchase Cross-Sell 2.0 LIVE

Trigger: Placed Order  β†’  ID: V3cgCb  |  50 actions, 47 live β€” well-built

Post-Delivery: New Customer LIVE

Trigger: Order Delivered  β†’  ID: XEY7G9

Maverick SMS Thank You Video LIVE

Trigger: Placed Order  β†’  ID: Xbb8Hb

Review Request (Okendo) LIVE

Trigger: Order Delivered  β†’  ID: XdaRXj

Paper Run 30D Post-Purchase Upsell LIVE

Trigger: Added to List (30d post-purchase)  β†’  ID: Tu3Zj5

Transactional / CX Flows LIVE

Triggers: parcelLab events  β†’  Multiple IDs
πŸ”

Stage 6: Retention β†’ Winback β†’ Sunset

If they don't come back within 90+ days

Winback Flows (Legacy) LIVE

Trigger: 90+ days since last order  β†’  9+ flows
Winback Master planned: 1 unified flow, 3 paths (1x / 2x / 3x+), 18 emails + 7 SMS, progressive discount ladders. Currently fragmented across 9+ legacy flows with 0.047% conv. Target: 0.25–0.50%.

Sunset Flow LIVE

Trigger: Added to List (90d inactive)  β†’  ID: VugMAt

πŸ”Ž Key Findings & Refresh Opportunities

HIGH PRIORITY

1. Cart/Checkout "10% Off" Email Links to PDP, Not Cart

Hov's screenshot shows a "Don't Wait Too Long β€” 10% off" email with a generic "Check Out" CTA that goes to PDP, not the abandoned cart/checkout URL. This breaks the reconversion path. Cart/checkout abandon emails should deep-link to the saved cart or checkout with items pre-loaded. This likely applies across all Cart Abandon emails (#2, #3, #4) and possibly Checkout Abandon as well.

HIGH PRIORITY

2. Abandoned Checkout Is the Messiest Flow β€” 40 Actions, 2 Generations of Content

WNRm6D has old Branch A emails (#1-#3, #6 numbering gap), new Branch B [ED] emails (Prospect/Customer), sitewide sale drafts for both, and draft leftovers from pre-rebuild. A new customer entering this flow could see 4–6 emails depending on the branch. Branch B is the winner (+14% RPR) but only gets 43% of traffic. Recommendation: kill Branch A, make Branch B the sole path, clean up dead drafts.

HIGH PRIORITY

3. No Discount Ladder β€” 10% at Every Stage

A new customer sees 10% off in: Welcome Email #4, Cart Abandon Emails #2–#4, Checkout Abandon Email #4 (both branches), and Browse Abandon Email #3 A/B test. There's no escalation β€” it's 10% everywhere. If they've ignored 10% off three times, offering it again won't convert them. Consider: no discount in browse β†’ 10% in cart β†’ 15% in checkout final touch, or use different hooks (free shipping, bundle incentive, membership).

MEDIUM

4. Triple Duplication: Main / Reclaim / Triple Whale Variants

Every abandon flow exists in 3 copies: Klaviyo-native, Reclaim/OpenSend, Triple Whale. Same content, just different lead sources. This triples maintenance burden for any update. Consider consolidating with smart trigger conditions or entry filters rather than duplicating entire flows.

MEDIUM

5. No Prospect/Customer Split in Cart Abandon (Only in Checkout)

The Checkout Abandon flow has a winning Prospect vs Customer branch ([ED] rebuild). The Cart Abandon flow still sends the same emails to everyone β€” first-time visitors and repeat buyers. Extending the segmentation to Cart Abandon would likely yield similar lifts (Customers convert at 1.88Γ— the rate of Prospects in checkout).

MEDIUM

6. Browse Abandon Conversion Rate Is Very Low (0.16%)

802K recipients β†’ 1,288 orders. The emails are fine ("See Something You Like?", social proof, guarantee) but the sheer volume dilutes conversion. No Prospect/Customer split here either. The A/B test on Email #3 ("10% OFF" vs editorial) hasn't been called yet. This is the highest-volume flow β€” even small improvements at 800K sends compound fast.

MEDIUM

7. Post-Purchase Master Needs More Time

388 orders/mo at 0.09% conv from 443K recipients. Went live recently (Jun 2026) with 1x/2x/3x branching. Some messages returned API errors (likely still being finalized). This flow is the single biggest revenue opportunity β€” benchmark is $344K–$689K/mo, current is ~$58K/mo.

IMPROVEMENT

8. No SMS in Any Pre-Purchase Abandon Flow

Zero SMS in cart or checkout abandon flows. Cart + checkout email recipients total ~195K/mo β€” even a small SMS follow-up to non-openers could recapture significant revenue. Currently SMS only exists in the Maverick post-purchase video.

IMPROVEMENT

9. Sitewide Sale Swaps Are Manual

Every flow has draft "Sitewide Sale" variants that get manually swapped Live↔Draft during promotions. Some flows are missing sale variants (e.g., Checkout Branch B has no Sale Email #3). Consider building this as a conditional branch (if sale active β†’ show sale content) instead of manual swaps.